A bull shark is one heavyweight species (Carcharhinus leucas). It is stocky and deep-bodied, with a short, blunt snout and small eyes, and it can live in fresh water. 'Reef shark' is a looser label for several slimmer species, such as the whitetip, blacktip and grey reef sharks, that live on coral reefs and are easiest to tell apart by the markings on their fins.
LiveAboard.com doesn't sponsor this post and doesn't see it before it's published - we recommend them because it's useful information for planning your trip. If you book through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Picture the surface interval. Someone on the sundeck is scrolling through their GoPro footage and announces, with total confidence, that they just swam with a bull shark. You lean in. The shark is about a metre and a half long and as slender as a pencil, and it is sleeping under a ledge with bright white tips on its fins. That's a whitetip reef shark, and it's having a far more relaxed morning than anyone on the boat. Mixing up these sharks happens on every liveaboard, so here's how to get it right before you start telling people about it at dinner.
Bull shark vs reef shark: the quick version
The biggest thing to understand is that 'bull shark' is one species, while 'reef shark' covers a group. Calling something a reef shark is a bit like calling a bird a garden bird. It's true, but it doesn't tell you which one. The reef sharks most divers meet are the whitetip reef shark (Triaenodon obesus), the blacktip reef shark and the grey reef shark in the Indo-Pacific, plus the Caribbean reef shark in the Atlantic.
The bull shark is a different kind of animal. According to FishBase, it is a massive shark with a short, broad, blunt snout and small eyes. Most references put its maximum length at around 3.5 m, and FishBase lists maturity at roughly 1.8 to 2.3 m. Most whitetip reef sharks, by comparison, stay under about 1.6 m. A big bull shark doesn't really cruise past. It moves through the water as if it pays rent there.
The ID checklist: what to look for underwater
Body shape is your first clue. Bull sharks are thick and deep-bodied, and they look wide even from the front. Reef sharks are built more like sports cars. The whitetip in particular is long and slim, which helps it squeeze into crevices after prey.
Next, look at the snout. A bull shark's snout is so short and rounded that the head looks almost flattened. The snouts of most reef sharks are more pointed and look more 'sharky'.
Then check the fin tips, which do most of the work:
Whitetip reef shark: bright white tips on the first dorsal fin and the upper lobe of the tail. It is grey-brown and slim, and it's often lying perfectly still on the bottom.
Blacktip reef shark: bold black tips on the first dorsal fin and the lower lobe of the tail, as if someone dipped it in ink.
Grey reef shark: a broad black band along the whole rear edge of the tail, dark tips on the other fins, and usually a plain first dorsal fin.
Bull shark: no bold markings. It is plain grey on top and pale underneath. The first dorsal fin is large and broadly triangular, and the second dorsal is much smaller.
Insider tip: In the Caribbean, the bull shark's classic look-alike is the Caribbean reef shark. Look at the shark's back between its two dorsal fins. A Caribbean reef shark has a low ridge of skin running along there, called an interdorsal ridge, and a bull shark doesn't. FishBase lists the missing ridge as one of the features that separate the bull shark from similar species. You'll mostly spot it in photos, so shoot side-on and check on the boat.
How they behave: napping, patrolling and the hunch
Behaviour gives the game away as often as fins do. Whitetip reef sharks are mostly nocturnal. During the day they rest on the sand or tuck themselves into caves and under ledges, often stacked together like sleeping bags at a festival. Unlike many sharks, they can pump water over their gills while lying still, so they don't have to keep swimming to breathe. At night they wake up and hunt in groups, working the reef for fish, crustaceans and octopus. If you do night dives in the Indo-Pacific, you'll see their other side, and it's a lot busier than the daytime nap.
Grey reef sharks are the patrollers. They cruise along walls and channel mouths, and they have a famous warning signal. If a diver follows or corners one, it may hunch its back, drop its pectoral fins and swim with an exaggerated side-to-side wiggle. That isn't a dance, so give it space. The display gets more intense when the shark feels boxed in.
Bull sharks have a habit the common reef sharks don't share: they can tolerate fresh water for long periods. They are known to swim up coastal river systems, sometimes a long way inland. Reef sharks, by contrast, stick mostly to reefs and nearby coastal waters. Underwater, bull sharks usually come in slow and close with a heavy, unhurried confidence that makes everyone on the dive check their buddy is still there. Your air consumption will tell you which one you saw before your brain does.
Where you'll actually meet each one
On a typical tropical reef dive in the Indo-Pacific, the odds favour reef sharks. Whitetips are usually recorded at around 8 to 40 m, so they turn up on ordinary recreational dives, often in the first cave you peer into. In places like Raja Ampat and Komodo, blacktip and whitetip reef sharks are the sharks most divers will see. Grey reef sharks are more patchy than many guidebooks suggest. In Raja Ampat they are mainly seen in Misool in the south, and they aren't common in Komodo. (If your guide promises greys in the Dampier Strait and then says 'they were here yesterday', you've been warned.)
Bull sharks are a more deliberate trip. Most divers see them at a few well-known sites where they gather in predictable numbers, often on organised shark dives.
If you're not sure what just swam past, Fins can help. Take a photo or grab a frame from your video, and the app will identify the species and tell you which ID features to check. It saves a lot of arguing on the sundeck, and it also helps the person who logged a whitetip as a bull shark take it gracefully.
Where to see bull sharks and reef sharks
Playa del Carmen, Mexico (bull sharks): Female bull sharks gather off the coast at Shark Point. Local reports put the season at roughly November to March, and the peak is usually December to February. Diving in Mexico
Beqa Lagoon, Fiji (bull sharks plus reef sharks): The Shark Reef Marine Reserve off Pacific Harbour on Viti Levu was set up in 2004 with local villages. Bull sharks are the headliners on its well-known feeding dives, and several reef shark species turn up too. Diving Viti Levu
Raja Ampat, Indonesia (reef sharks): Blacktips and whitetips are common across the region, and Misool is the place to go for grey reef sharks. Diving Raja Ampat
Komodo, Indonesia (reef sharks): Blacktip and whitetip reef sharks are the regulars here, and brown-banded bamboo sharks are a bonus. Diving Komodo National Park
FAQ
Is a bull shark a type of reef shark?
No. The bull shark is its own species, Carcharhinus leucas. It can visit reefs, but it also lives in coastal waters, estuaries and even rivers. 'Reef shark' usually refers to species such as the whitetip, blacktip, grey and Caribbean reef sharks.
What is the easiest way to tell a bull shark from a reef shark?
Look at the snout and the fins. A bull shark is bulky, with a short, blunt snout and no bold fin markings. Most reef sharks are slimmer and have clear white or black tips or edges on their fins.
How big do bull sharks get compared to reef sharks?
Most references give a maximum length of about 3.5 m for bull sharks. Whitetip reef sharks usually stay under about 1.6 m.
Are whitetip reef sharks endangered?
The IUCN lists the whitetip reef shark as Vulnerable, largely because of fishing pressure across its range.
Next time someone on the boat swears they saw a bull shark, you'll know what to ask: how thick was it, how blunt was the snout and what colour were the fin tips? Then you can let the photo settle it. Fins identifies sharks, rays and reef fish from your dive photos, so you can log the right species and spend your surface interval enjoying the encounter instead of arguing about it. Download Fins and find out exactly who you were diving with.