What is it like to dive the Brothers, Daedalus and Elphinstone? Sharks, currents and the open Red Sea

Photo: No machine-readable author provided. Peterkoelbl assumed (based on copyright claims). / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA)

Diving Egypt's Brothers, Daedalus and Elphinstone means drifting along sheer offshore walls in open water, often in strong current, far from the busy coastal reefs. The encounters people come for are oceanic whitetip sharks, schooling scalloped hammerheads and grey reef sharks patrolling the reef edge.

LiveAboard.com doesn't sponsor this guide and doesn't see it before it's published - we recommend them because it's useful information for planning your trip. If you book through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Picture a lighthouse standing on a scrap of rock in the middle of the Red Sea, with nothing around it but deep blue water in every direction. Below the waterline the reef drops away into water deep enough that the blue just goes darker until you stop looking. That is the offshore Red Sea. The Brothers, Daedalus and Elphinstone are where Egyptian diving stops being an easy week of coral gardens and starts to feel like an expedition. Everyone does the deep-water drop at the start of the dive, then hangs in the blue staring at nothing. Then something long and grey turns up out of nowhere and all of a sudden everyone is breathing twice as fast. This trip suits experienced divers who are comfortable with negative entries, blue-water safety stops and the occasional zodiac pickup in a choppy sea. If you already know you want to go, you can compare boats and dates on LiveAboard.com. If you are still deciding, read on - this is a trip where knowing what you are getting into makes a real difference.

When is the best time to dive the Brothers, Daedalus and Elphinstone?

Boats run to the offshore reefs for most of the year, but which shark you are most likely to see changes with the season. Very roughly, the year splits into a warm half and a cool half.

Summer (roughly May to August): hammerhead season

Scalloped hammerheads are most commonly reported in late spring and summer, especially at Daedalus and the Brothers. Operator guides most often give May to August, and some narrow the peak to May and June. The water is at its warmest in summer, reaching around 30C at the surface at the peak. A 3mm or 5mm full suit is plenty for most divers.

Autumn into early winter (roughly September to December): oceanic whitetip season

Oceanic whitetips are reported across much of the year, but autumn is the season most guides point to, especially at Elphinstone and the Brothers. The water is still warm early in the season and cools as winter comes on. A 5mm suit covers most of this period.

Winter (roughly January to April): cooler water, rougher crossings

Surface temperatures drop to roughly 21-23C. On paper that doesn't sound cold, but after your fourth dive of the day it can feel pretty cold. A 5mm suit with a hood, or a 7mm, makes sense. Thresher sharks are reported more often in the cooler months, particularly at the Brothers. Winter winds can also make the open-water crossings bumpier, so pack seasickness tablets even if you think you won't need them.

Insider tip: Some boats only offer certain itineraries at certain times of year. If you want one particular animal more than anything else, choose your dates for that first and then pick the boat.

Carcharhinus amblyrhynchos
Photo: CRED/PIFSC, NOAA / Wikimedia Commons (CC0 Public Domain)

The Brothers: two islands, two wrecks and the sharky one

The Brothers (El Akhawein) are two small islands rising out of deep water roughly 60-70 km offshore from El Quseir. Big Brother is the larger of the two. It has a stone lighthouse, built by the British in 1883, and two well-known wrecks. Little Brother is smaller, about 1 km to the south, and has a reputation as the sharkier of the pair.

The walls are steep, covered in soft corals and sea fans, and swept by current that can switch direction during a dive. Visibility is generally excellent out here, because there is no runoff from the land to cloud the water. Most dives are drifts or follow the current along the wall. Morning dives often focus on the exposed plateaus at the tips of the islands, where sharks patrol the edge of the current.

On Big Brother the Numidia is the headline wreck. She was a British cargo steamer, built for the Calcutta run, that ran aground on the reef in 1901 while carrying railway cargo bound for India. She lies steeply down the reef slope, and after more than a century she is covered in coral. Nearby is the Aida, an Egyptian supply ship lost in the 1950s while trying to reach the lighthouse pier.

Commonly encountered animals include grey reef shark (Carcharhinus amblyrhynchos), oceanic whitetip shark (Carcharhinus longimanus) in season, and, if you are lucky, pelagic thresher shark (Alopias pelagicus). Threshers are reported more in the cooler months and early in the morning. Scalloped hammerheads also turn up here in summer.

Who it suits: experienced divers only. Many operators require at least 50 logged dives for the Brothers, and some cite Egyptian marine park rules for this. Access: liveaboard only.

Insider tip: On the Brothers, dive plans revolve around the current, not the clock. Listen to the briefing for which way it is running that morning, because the same plateau can be an easy drift one day and something to fight the next. Agree with your buddy before you go that you won't push into it.

You can browse boats that include the islands on the LiveAboard.com Brothers page.

Sphyrna lewini
Photo: Kris Mikael Krister / iNaturalist (CC BY)

Daedalus: a lighthouse in the middle of nowhere

Daedalus (Abu el Kizan) is a lone reef roughly 80-90 km offshore, east of Marsa Alam, with an active lighthouse standing on the reef. Under the surface, the walls drop off into deep open water on every side. It is a protected area, and divers pay a marine park fee, often collected on board.

Daedalus is famous for scalloped hammerhead (Sphyrna lewini). Groups of them are regularly reported around the northern plateau in summer. The Important Shark and Ray Areas (ISRA) factsheet describes groups of up to 10. Some operators and dive reports describe much bigger schools. They usually cruise in deeper water off the edge of the plateau. On a good morning they come up into recreational depths. That is when your guide's carefully calm hand signals turn into something closer to interpretive dance. Scalloped hammerheads are assessed as Critically Endangered globally, so every sighting matters.

On the reef itself, look for the gorgonians and soft corals along the walls. Shoals of Red Sea anthias (Pseudanthias squamipinnis) pour off the reef edge, and humphead wrasse (Cheilinus undulatus) cruise past and check you out at close range. Grey reef sharks and, in season, oceanic whitetips round out the shark list.

Who it suits: advanced divers comfortable with blue-water drifts. Operators commonly ask for Advanced Open Water certification or equivalent and at least 50 logged dives. Access: liveaboard only. More details are on the LiveAboard.com Daedalus page.

Insider tip: Hammerhead dives at Daedalus usually mean leaving the reef and hanging in open blue water. That is where an SMB and good buoyancy control stop being optional extras. If you don't like having no visual reference, practise a few mid-water safety stops on the earlier dives of the trip.

Elphinstone: the shark reef you can reach by day boat

Elphinstone is a long, narrow reef roughly 10 km off the coast, north of Marsa Alam. The walls on both sides are covered in soft corals. At each end there is a plateau that runs out into deep water. The north and south plateaus are where the action tends to be: current-swept points where pelagics come in from the blue.

Elphinstone's star is the oceanic whitetip shark (Carcharhinus longimanus), commonly encountered from autumn into early winter. Oceanics are bold, curious sharks that often swim up near the surface. They will slowly circle a group of divers with their huge, rounded, white-tipped pectoral fins spread wide, often with pilot fish riding along in front of their nose. They are thrilling to watch and they deserve real respect. Guides will brief you to stay in a tight group, keep close to the reef or the boat, and never splash about at the surface. Follow those rules. Grey reef sharks also patrol the plateaus.

Who it suits: experienced divers. Strong currents make it a site for divers who are comfortable with drifts and depth, and requirements vary by operator, so check before you book. Access: this is the only one of the three reefs you can reach by day boat from the Marsa Alam coast. It is also a common first or last stop on Brothers and Daedalus liveaboard routes. See the LiveAboard.com Elphinstone page for boats that call here.

Insider tip: Elphinstone can get busy with day boats and liveaboards, especially in high season. A liveaboard can often dive it first thing in the morning, before the reef gets busy.

What marine life will you see in the offshore Red Sea?

Big animals

Sharks are the main reason people come out here. The key species are oceanic whitetip (Carcharhinus longimanus), scalloped hammerhead (Sphyrna lewini), grey reef shark (Carcharhinus amblyrhynchos) and, more rarely, pelagic thresher (Alopias pelagicus). Big humphead wrasse are regulars on the reefs too. None of it is guaranteed. Every guide has said they were here yesterday at least once in their career, and they meant it.

Reef life

The walls themselves are spectacular, and well worth a look between shark sightings. Commonly encountered fish include Red Sea anthias (Pseudanthias squamipinnis) and Red Sea bannerfish (Heniochus intermedius). You will also see the masked butterflyfish (Chaetodon semilarvatus), which is found almost only in the Red Sea and the Gulf of Aden, the Red Sea clownfish (Amphiprion bicinctus) in its anemone, and giant moray (Gymnothorax javanicus) tucked into cracks in the reef.

Macro

Small critters are not why people book this trip, but they are there if you look. Check the sea fans for longnose hawkfish (Oxycirrhites typus), and look closely at the coral heads around the wrecks on Big Brother. Just don't be the photographer who spends the whole dive on one goby while a hammerhead swims past behind them. Everyone on the boat will hear about it at dinner.

Liveaboard or land-based?

For the Brothers and Daedalus, the decision is made for you: they are liveaboard only. Elphinstone is the one exception, because you can reach it by day boat from resorts around Marsa Alam.

Liveaboard pros: you get to all three reefs on one trip, you can dive early before other boats arrive, and you get several dives a day at sites the day boats can't reach. Most trips last a week, and the classic itinerary is a seven-night trip that combines all three. Liveaboard cons: long open-water crossings that can be rough, a fair amount of time on zodiacs, and no backing out halfway through.

Land-based pros: a stable bed, the freedom to have a day off, and an easy way for a non-diving partner to come along. Land-based cons: you only get Elphinstone, and you share it with every other day boat on the coast.

If you are qualified and you want the sharks, a liveaboard is the way to do it. You can compare offshore itineraries side by side on LiveAboard.com.

How do you get to the Brothers, Daedalus and Elphinstone?

The two main international gateways are Hurghada International Airport (HRG) and Marsa Alam International Airport (RMF). Brothers, Daedalus and Elphinstone liveaboards usually leave from the Hurghada area or from Port Ghalib near Marsa Alam, depending on the boat and the route. Many operators arrange the transfer from the airport to the boat. Check which airport and port your boat uses before you book flights, because the drive between Hurghada and Port Ghalib takes around three hours or more. Entry requirements for Egypt change, so check the current rules for your nationality before you travel.

Planning tips for the offshore reefs

Booking your trip

Offshore itineraries fill up fast in hammerhead and oceanic whitetip season, so it pays to plan early.

Why I recommend LiveAboard.com

I've worked on liveaboards for 13 years. I've booked through LiveAboard.com many times, and so have a lot of my guests. They don't sponsor Fins and they don't see what we write. Here's why I point people to them:

If you're not sure which boat or itinerary is right for you, they're a great place to start: compare liveaboards in Egypt's Brothers, Daedalus and Elphinstone.

Before you go: get Fins

Know what you're looking at. Fins is a marine life ID app built by divers. Before your trip, use it to get to know the animals you're likely to meet. After each dive, identify what you saw from a photo, or answer a few simple questions if you didn't get a shot, and keep it all in your dive log. Download Fins before you fly.

Before the trip, learn to tell a grey reef shark from a silvertip and an oceanic whitetip at a glance. That way the excited debrief on the sundeck can turn into an actual ID with Fins.

FAQ: diving the Brothers, Daedalus and Elphinstone

How many logged dives do I need for the Brothers?

Many operators require at least 50 logged dives for the Brothers, along with Advanced Open Water or equivalent, and some cite Egyptian marine park rules for this. Check with your boat, because requirements vary and can change.

When is the best time to see hammerheads at Daedalus?

Scalloped hammerheads are most commonly reported from late spring through summer, roughly May to August, with many guides pointing to May and June. Sightings are never guaranteed.

When is the best season for oceanic whitetips?

Autumn into early winter, roughly September to December, is the period most often recommended, especially at Elphinstone and the Brothers. They are reported at other times of year too.

Can I dive Elphinstone without a liveaboard?

Yes. Elphinstone is the one offshore reef of the three that day boats from the Marsa Alam coast can reach. The Brothers and Daedalus are liveaboard only.

What wetsuit should I bring?

A 3mm to 5mm suit is fine in summer, when surface water reaches around 30C. In winter, when it drops to roughly 21-23C, bring a 5mm with a hood or a 7mm.

Is it safe to dive with oceanic whitetips?

Yes, if you follow your guide's briefing: stay in a group, stay close to the reef, avoid splashing at the surface and never feed or chase the sharks. They are curious animals that deserve respect, not panic.

The offshore Red Sea rewards divers who come prepared: good buoyancy, a working SMB and the patience to keep watching the blue. Get the logbook in order, choose your season, and before you board, Download Fins so that when a shark comes up out of the deep you will know exactly which one you are looking at.